Merkeley vs. Merkeley

Watching today's single-chair US Senate debate with Jeff Merkeley vs. the empty podium where Gordon Smith should have been, I have to call it a narrow Merkeley victory.

Victory because the world gets run by the people who show up, and Smith didn't. And narrow because Merkeley came across as a mildly clever man with a hat full of memorized sound bites.

Note to future debate prep staff: remind the candidate that a sound bite is like a spice -- use sparingly to accent the main course. Rely on them too much, and it burns the tongue and insults the palate. So too with Merkeley, who said "giveaways to the richest Americans" perhaps a dozen too many times.

Working the sound bite into one answer is good. Two can be better if they're far enough apart. Three or more answers in quick succession, all containing that same sound bite, and you sound like a performer repeating memorized lines. (Oh, and it sounds even lamer if you then stumble over it.)

Yes the room was filled with upper middle class liberals who might not have been terribly open to Smith anyway. Nevertheless Smith owed it to all the voters to show up and make his case. Had he handled himself well, Smith could have raised doubts about Merkeley's intellect (actually Merkeley managed to raise them himself, in my mind at least) and shown off the bipartisanship that has so distanced him from his own reluctant Jesus-loving base.